Print Page   |   Contact Us   |   Report Abuse   |   Sign In
Pro Hac Vice
Share |

Pro Hac Vice

For questions or additional information, contact Kathie Lynch at klynch@montanabar.org or (406) 447-2210.

 

 


Rules

From the 2009 AMENDED RULES FOR ADMISSION TO THE BAR OF MONTANA
Supreme Court of the State of Montana, Order 00-329, March 3, 2009; amended by Order AF 11-0244, July 31, 2012.

IV. PRO HAC VICE

A. Upon written application, an attorney who is not admitted to practice law in the state courts of Montana and who is at the time admitted and authorized to practice law in the highest court of another state may appear pro hac vice in any action or proceeding, if an attorney admitted to practice in the courts of Montana is associated as attorney of record.

B. An attorney may not appear pro hac vice under this section if the attorney is a resident of Montana, is regularly employed in Montana, or is regularly engaged in the practice of law or in substantial business or professional activities in Montana, unless the attorney has an application for admission pending with the Bar Admissions Administrator of the State Bar of Montana.

C. Except upon a showing of good cause, no attorney or firm may appear pro hac vice in more than two actions or proceedings in any state court or administrative agency in Montana. Upon an attorney or firm's second appearance pro hac vice, no further pro hac vice appearances are permitted except upon a showing of good cause. Findings of good cause to exceed the two-appearance limit are not to be routinely granted. For purposes of this rule, "good cause" includes, by way of example only, a showing that the attorney or firm seeking to appear pro hac vice possesses experience or expertise not commonly available in the membership of the State Bar of Montana or where the attorney or firm is acting as counsel in a multi-state class action. (For purposes of this rule, only those appearances made after November 17, 1998, shall be considered.)

D. Applications for pro hac vice must be obtained from the State Bar of Montana. The application form will require that the applicant provide the following information:

1. the applicant's residence and office addresses;

2. the state and federal courts to which the applicant has been admitted to practice and the dates of admission;

3. whether the applicant is a member in good standing in those courts;

4. whether the applicant is currently suspended or disbarred in any court and, if so, a description of the circumstances under which the suspension or disbarment occurred;

5. whether the applicant has been formally notified of any complaints pending before a disciplinary agency in any other jurisdiction and, if so, a description of the nature and status of any pending disciplinary complaints;

6. an identification of all law firms with which the applicant is associated and a description of all pending pro hac vice appearances of the applicant's firm(s) in Montana;

7. the title of each state court and cause in which the applicant has filed an application to appear as counsel pro hac vice, the date of each application, and whether it was granted;

8. the name, address, and telephone number of the active member of the State Bar of Montana who is the attorney of record;

9. an affirmation that the applicant will comply with the applicable statutes, law, and procedural rules of the state of Montana; be familiar with and comply with the Montana Rules of Professional Conduct; and submit to the jurisdiction of the Montana courts, the Montana disciplinary process, and the State Bar of Montana with respect to acts and omissions occurring during appearances under this rule; and

10. whether payment has been made to the State Bar of Montana in accordance with the requirements of Section IV(D) of these rules.

The completed application, along with a fee of $385 must be filed with the State Bar of Montana (see order effective Oct. 1, 2012). The application will then be reviewed by the State Bar of Montana which shall certify the number of prior appearances the applicant has been granted under Section IV-C, whether or not the applicant has provided the requisite information, whether or not the applicant is in good standing in the other jurisdiction(s) where admitted, and whether or not Montana counsel is in good standing. Upon certification, the State Bar shall forward the application to the appropriate court or agency. The court or agency shall enter an order granting or refusing the application and, if the applicant is refused, the court or agency shall state its reasons. A copy of the court's order shall be mailed to the applicant, counsel of record and the State Bar of Montana. The State Bar of Montana shall maintain a record of all pro hac vice applications as a public record. Attorneys appearing pro hac vice shall notify the State Bar of Montana upon conclusion of the matter in which the attorney appeared.

E. An attorney appearing pro hac vice under this section is subject to the jurisdiction of the Montana courts with respect to Montana law governing the conduct of attorneys to the same extent as an attorney admitted to practice in the courts of this state. The attorney shall comply with the Montana Rules of Professional Conduct and is subject to the disciplinary jurisdiction of the Montana Supreme Court. The court or agency in which an attorney is appearing pro hac vice or the Montana Supreme Court may, for violations of Montana law, the Montana Rules of Professional Conduct, Rules for Admission to the Bar of Montana, or orders of the court, withdraw its permission for an attorney to appear pro hac vice.

F. Montana attorneys of record shall sign all pleadings, motions, and briefs and participate actively in all phases of the case, including, but not limited to, discovery responses and briefs, and all other activities necessary to be prepared to go forward with the case at all times. A district court or agency, upon motion by local counsel, may waive this rule based upon a showing of extraordinary circumstances. Upon waiver of the rule by the district court or agency, all papers subsequently filed shall be signed by counsel actively involved in the case. Such a waiver is not to be routinely granted.

G. Attorneys admitted pro hac vice will continue to pay annual dues and fees each year for the term of the Montana litigation or until such time that the State Bar of Montana is advised that the attorney has withdrawn from representation. However, for a lawyer who is appearing pro bono as defined under Rule 6.1 of the Rules of Professional Conduct, the pro hac vice fee shall be a one-time-only fee equal to the amount paid annually by active members of the Montana Bar.

>Pro Hac Vice Application Form (Allow 5 working days for processing)

 

Frequently Asked Questions

How to I file for pro hac vice and what is the fee?

An application needs to be sent along with $385 per attorney to the State Bar of Montana. Attorneys admitted pro hac vice will continue to pay annual dues and fees each year for the term of the Montana litigation or until such time that the State Bar of Montana is advised that the attorney has withdrawn from representation. However, for a lawyer who is appearing pro bono as defined under Rule 6.1 of the Rules of Professional Conduct, the pro hac vice fee shall be a one-time-only fee equal to the amount paid annually by active members of the Montana Bar.

What is the process after you receive my application?

 

The rules above and the application will provide more information. The Bar will then verify that all attorneys are in good standing in the states they’re currently licensed and the number of appearances had by the attorney and their firm. Letters will be mailed to the attorneys and the clerk advising of the status of this information. (The State Bar does not approve or deny applications, as that is up to the discretion of the court hearing the matter.)

What do I file with the Court?

In most courts, an attorney seeking to appear pro hac vice will need to file a motion and proposed order accompanied by a copy of the State Bar of Montana pro hac vice Application and confirmation correspondence from the Bar. (Please notify the State Bar whether the court approved or denied the appearance.)


Will I be reminded when the annual assessment is due each year?

Yes, the Bar will send an invoice to each pro hac vice attorney until we’re notified that the matter has been settled or closed. The invoice will show the amount of the dues and fees payable.


Do I need to file an application if my case is in federal court?

No. For information about filing pro hac vice in the US Courts in Montana, please go to their website at http://www.mtd.uscourts.gov.


Payment of Dues when case is stayed

A lawyer who has been admitted pro hac vice under the Bar admission rules continues under that status until the conclusion of the legal matter for which she or he has been admitted—unless the lawyer properly withdraws before the conclusion of the case. There is no exception regarding the procedural posture of the case.


What is the procedure if local counsel withdraws who is supervising an attorney appearing pro hac vice?

The Court has a great amount of latitude whether to allow withdrawal of local counsel and assumption of not only the case by new counsel, but the duties of local counsel to supervise the pro hac attorney. Rule F of the Pro Hac Vice Rules state as follows: "Montana attorneys of record shall sign all pleadings, motions and briefs and participate actively in all phases of the case, including, but not limited to, attendance at depositions and court or agency proceedings, preparation of discovery responses and briefs and all other activities necessary to be prepared to go forward with the case at all times. A district court or agency, upon motion by local counsel, may waive this rule based upon a showing of extraordinary circumstances. Upon waiver of the rule by the district court or agency, all papers subsequently filed shall be signed by counsel actively involved in the case. Such a waiver is not to be routinely granted."


Therefore, an attorney admitted pro hac vice may not continue in a case without local counsel associated to fully participate as cited in the rule above absent a "showing of extreme circumstances". Upon filing of a motion to substitute counsel or a motion to withdraw, the new counsel will need to notify the State Bar of Montana, in writing, that he will be assuming duties of local counsel and the responsibility to oversee the pro hac vice attorney. The Bar will then verify the good standing of local counsel and send the court and attorney a letter verifying the new local counsel’s status and substitution for previous counsel. It’s then up to the court to grant or deny the substitution.


Amicus Filings  Out of state counsel is required to associate with local counsel and to file pro hac vice if they’re filing an amicus brief.